Getting tired of hearing this...the David Tyree catch was BETTER. Great catch by Manningham, no doubt, but the one Tyree did was BETTER! He had to stretch out for that ball, trap it against his helmet, with a defender draped on him!!! Manningham's catch was just an over the shoulder catch. I give Manning more credit for his accuracy on that throw.
Oh one other thing, many former players/coaches are saying that Manningham catch was a result of poor technique in cover 2. So in other words, better technique by the Patiots, and maybe that catch doesn't even happen.